# Carvana Co. (CVNA) — Business, Risks and Management's Discussion Period covered: third quarter of fiscal 2026 (quarter ended September 30, 2026). Carvana's fiscal year is the calendar year. ## Business *From the Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025 (accession 0001690820-26-000009).* Carvana is an e-commerce retailer of used cars in the United States. Consumers browse, finance, buy, trade in or sell a vehicle through its website and app, and Carvana delivers the car to their home or hands it over at one of its branded multi-story "vending machine" towers or other pickup sites. Revenue comes from four streams tied to each retail sale: the vehicle itself (retail vehicle sales, $14.5 billion in 2025), wholesale sales of trade-ins and other acquired vehicles that do not meet retail standards plus fees from its ADESA wholesale auction marketplace ($4.1 billion), and "other sales and revenues" ($1.7 billion) — chiefly gains on selling the auto loans it originates, plus commissions on vehicle service contracts (VSCs), GAP waiver coverage and Root auto insurance. Other sales and revenues carry a 100% gross margin, so they contribute a disproportionate share of profit. Substantially all revenue and assets are in the U.S., and the company reports a single operating segment. How the model works: - **Sourcing.** Inventory is bought directly from consumers (instant online offers, with home pickup), at auctions including its own digital auction platform, and from wholesale suppliers and retail marketplace partners. Buying from consumers avoids auction fees and is more profitable on average. - **Reconditioning.** Vehicles go to inspection and reconditioning centers (IRCs) or ADESA auction sites with reconditioning capability. The network had capacity to recondition about 1.5 million vehicles a year at full utilization as of December 31, 2025. The 2022 acquisition of ADESA US Auction added 56 locations; 16 had been built out with IRC capability by year-end 2025, and the company is progressively combining retail and wholesale operations at those sites. - **Financing.** A proprietary credit-scoring and deal-structuring platform, trained on more than ten years of Carvana-originated loans, presents customers with instant financing terms. Carvana classifies these loans as held for sale and does not intend to hold them to maturity: it sells them into securitizations it sponsors, under a committed forward-flow agreement with Ally (the Ally MPSA) and through fixed-pool sales to third-party purchasers. - **Logistics and fulfillment.** An in-house hub-and-spoke network spanning 316 metropolitan statistical areas services over 80% of the U.S. population. Carvana estimated that 75% of the population was within 100 miles of an IRC or auction site at year-end 2025. It operates 39 vending machines. - **Scale.** Since launching in 2013 Carvana had sold 2.8 million retail vehicles and generated $84.1 billion of cumulative revenue through December 31, 2025. It held over 75,000 website units, employed more than 23,100 people and had at least one licensed facility in 40 states. The company estimates its share of the roughly 37 million-unit U.S. used-vehicle retail market (Cox Automotive, 2024) at about 1.6%; the market is highly fragmented, with the top ten used retailers holding under 10%. - **Franchise dealerships.** In 2025 Carvana acquired five franchise dealerships for $160 million in total consideration ($101 million cash, $59 million of trade vehicle floor plan payables). It also set up a $214 million floor plan line with Stellantis Financial Services to finance new-vehicle inventory at those stores. The company competes with traditional used-car dealers such as CarMax, with online automotive listing sites, with membership buying programs, with manufacturers selling direct, and with private-party sales. It argues that its vertical integration — it controls pricing, financing terms, appraisal offers and logistics — gives it a structurally lower variable cost than traditional dealers. **Ownership structure.** Carvana Co. is a holding company whose only material asset is its interest in Carvana Group, LLC (an "Up-C" structure). It owned 64.7% of Carvana Group at December 31, 2025, and the remaining LLC unitholders held 35.3%. The founding Garcia family ("the Garcia Parties") holds Class B shares carrying ten votes each and controlled about 83% of the voting power at year-end 2025, which makes Carvana a "controlled company" under NYSE rules. DriveTime, which Carvana was spun off from and which the Garcia Parties control, is a related party: it administers Carvana's VSCs, services its loans, leases property to it and buys wholesale vehicles from it. ## Risk factors *From the FY2025 Form 10-K (accession 0001690820-26-000009), Item 1A. The Q3 2026 Form 10-Q (accession 0001690820-26-000067) reports no changes to these risk factors.* **Demand, prices and the macro environment** - **Consumer demand and affordability.** Vehicle purchases are discretionary and fall in recessions. Elevated or volatile interest rates and inflation raise monthly payments and reduce demand. Tariffs on vehicles and parts, military conflicts and supply-chain disruptions can change both vehicle supply and buying behavior. - **Used-vehicle price swings.** Rising used prices relative to new can push buyers toward new cars. Falling prices create markdown risk on inventory, which is a large share of total assets. Over-buying relative to demand has in the past lengthened days-to-sale and forced accelerated depreciation. - **Inventory sourcing.** The business depends on acquiring enough desirable vehicles and reconditioning parts, and on inventory financing staying available on acceptable terms. - **Competition.** Rivals range from CarMax and online platforms to automakers and new entrants with more capital. DriveTime itself could become a competitor, and it holds a limited license to some of Carvana's intellectual property. The company also flags autonomous vehicles, ride-sharing and generative AI as possible disruptors of the industry. **Loan sales and capital markets** - **Dependence on loan sales.** Gains on selling the loans it originates are a substantial portion of gross profit. Those gains depend on spreads between the rate quoted to the customer and market rates at sale, on forecast losses, and on investor appetite for auto ABS and whole loans. - **Funding access.** The company relies on committed forward-flow buyers, securitizations and fixed-pool purchasers. If a partner terminates, a commitment is used up, or securitization markets tighten, liquidity would suffer and it might have to retain credit risk. - **Contract errors and credit losses.** Auto-generated contracts that breach state rate caps could be unenforceable. Loans that fail sale representations must be repurchased. Loans held before sale, and retained securitization interests (at least 5% under the federal risk-retention rules), expose the company to credit and prepayment losses. **Leverage and liquidity** - **Substantial indebtedness.** At year-end 2025, debt included $3.9 billion of Senior Secured Notes, $107 million of Senior Unsecured Notes, $485 million of sale-leaseback financing, $374 million of financing against retained securitization interests, finance leases, fleet loans and floor-plan borrowings. Indenture covenants restrict additional debt, liens, dividends and asset sales. Variable-rate debt exposes the company to rising rates. **Structure and governance** - **Holding-company dependence.** Carvana Co. must rely on distributions from Carvana Group to pay its taxes, its debt and its Tax Receivable Agreement (TRA) obligations. - **Tax Receivable Agreement.** Carvana must pay LLC unitholders 85% of the tax benefits it realizes from unit exchanges, and it expects these payments to be substantial. They accelerate on a change of control or early termination, are not refunded if the IRS later disallows the benefits, and could deter an acquirer. - **Founder control.** The Garcia Parties can elect the whole board, decide all stockholder votes and block any change of control. Their interests, including in DriveTime, may conflict with other holders'. Dilution can come from LLC unit exchanges, equity plans and the at-the-market (ATM) share program. **Operational, legal and technology** - **Regulation.** The company is subject to dealer and finance licensing in each state, the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, consumer-protection, advertising and title/registration rules, Department of Transportation regulation of its fleet, and environmental rules. Licensing regulators have in the past, and may again, impose fines, suspend or revoke licenses, or otherwise bar it from buying, selling or financing vehicles in a state. State attorneys general periodically examine its inspection, titling, registration and lending practices. - **Reputation and service quality.** The model depends on trust. The company cites past complaints about timely delivery of titles and registration, and about vehicle quality, as examples of how lapses can damage the brand quickly through social media. - **Data, cybersecurity and AI.** The company holds sensitive customer financial data, including social security numbers and credit information. Breaches, system outages at its third-party hosts, and AI tools that malfunction or fall foul of fast-changing AI rules are each flagged as material risks. - **Litigation.** Disclosed matters include the consolidated securities class action pending in the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona, and, at the time of the 10-K, an SEC subpoena (June 2025) related to a January 2025 short-seller report. The SEC matter was later concluded without enforcement (see Current quarter). - **Root investment and acquisitions.** As a minority investor in Root (Series A preferred stock and warrants), Carvana has limited influence and has recorded fair-value declines on the warrants. Acquisitions such as its wholesale marketplace and the five franchise dealerships carry integration, liability and impairment risk. - **Insurance and people.** The company may be unable to obtain affordable insurance on its inventory and auto liability, and it depends on retaining key personnel. ## Management's discussion — fiscal 2025 *From the FY2025 Form 10-K (accession 0001690820-26-000009), Item 7.* 2025 was a year of rapid, profitable growth. Retail units sold rose 43.3% to 596,641 and total revenue rose 48.6% to $20.32 billion. Retail vehicle sales grew $4.9 billion to $14.5 billion, helped by higher revenue per retail unit ($24,365 versus $23,252) as fewer sales came through retail marketplace partners, whose transactions are booked net. Wholesale revenue rose $1.2 billion to $4.1 billion on 49% more wholesale units. Other sales and revenues rose $582 million to $1.7 billion. Management attributed that increase to higher loan-sale volume and loan-sale spreads and higher VSC attach rates, partly offset by lower interest income on loans held for sale. Gross profit rose 45.8% to $4.19 billion, and total gross profit per retail unit edged up to $7,026 from $6,908. Retail gross profit per unit was essentially flat at $3,315. Wholesale gross profit rose $135 million to $481 million, including a $32 million increase in marketplace gross profit to $179 million on 1,006,551 marketplace units. SG&A rose $434 million to $2.3 billion, mainly from headcount and advertising tied to volume. Interest expense fell $146 million to $505 million. Management attributed the decline to repurchasing and redeeming 2028 Senior Secured Notes ($611 million of principal), paying the 2025 Senior Unsecured Notes at maturity ($98 million), electing cash rather than payment-in-kind interest, and earning higher interest income. Net income was $1.895 billion (a 9.3% margin), against $404 million in 2024. The figure was shaped by two large, largely offsetting accounting items: - **Valuation allowance release.** Carvana concluded it was more likely than not to realize its deferred tax assets and released $2.2 billion of its valuation allowance. Together with $547 million of benefit from current-year activity, this produced a $2.8 billion income tax benefit. - **TRA liability.** Having concluded that those tax benefits would be used, Carvana judged its TRA payments probable. It recorded $2.2 billion of TRA expense within other expense, raising the TRA liability to $2.3 billion, of which $1.7 billion is owed to related parties. Adjusted EBITDA, the company's non-GAAP profit measure, was $2.237 billion (an 11.0% margin) against $1.378 billion (10.1%) in 2024. Tariffs did not materially affect 2025 results. **Liquidity and funding in 2025.** - **Cash flow.** Operating cash flow was $1.0 billion, up $118 million. Investing cash outflow rose to $230 million, mainly because of the five dealership acquisitions. - **Equity.** Carvana raised $539 million of gross proceeds under its ATM program. - **Debt.** Outstanding principal fell to $5.0 billion from $5.5 billion. - **Loan-sale commitments.** It expanded these substantially. The Ally MPSA was amended in October 2025 to a $6.0 billion purchase commitment through October 27, 2026. Three fixed-pool loan purchase agreements of up to $4.0 billion each, with independent third-party purchasers, run through late 2027. - **Fleet financing.** A loan agreement with Citizens Bank provides up to $250 million to finance transportation-fleet equipment. Short-term revolving facilities had $5.0 billion of total commitments at year-end, with $58 million drawn. ## Current quarter — Q3 2026 *From the Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (accession 0001690820-26-000067), and the shareholder letter and press release furnished as Exhibits 99.1 and 99.2 to the Form 8-K of October 28, 2026 (accession 0001690820-26-000066). Share and per-share figures reflect the five-for-one stock split effected May 8, 2026.* **Results.** Carvana sold 217,385 retail units in the third quarter, up 39.4% year over year and its first quarter above 200,000. Management noted the broader used-vehicle industry was roughly flat, so the growth came from market-share gains. Its current run rate implies about 870,000 units a year, roughly 2% of the used market. Revenue rose 42.4% to $8.04 billion: - **Retail vehicle sales** rose 53.8% to $6.14 billion. Revenue per retail unit rose to $28,263 from $25,625, which management attributed to overall appreciation in the retail market and a lower share of marketplace-partner sales. - **Wholesale revenue** rose 10.6% to $1.30 billion. Wholesale units grew 38.3%, but revenue per wholesale unit fell to $9,854 from $11,721, and wholesale marketplace revenue declined. - **Other sales and revenues** rose 25.3% to $594 million. Loan-sale volume was higher but loan-sale spreads were lower, and VSC, auto insurance and GAP commissions rose. Gross profit rose 32.5% to $1.52 billion, but total gross profit per retail unit fell $365 to $6,997 (non-GAAP: down $410 to $7,093). Management attributed the per-unit decline to three things: - **Lower loan rates for customers.** Its decision to give customers lower loan rates relative to benchmark rates. - **Lower wholesale gross profit per unit.** Retail units grew faster than wholesale marketplace gross profit. - **Offset: higher retail-to-wholesale spreads.** Partly offsetting these, spreads between retail and wholesale prices widened. By component, retail gross profit per unit rose $100 to $3,556, wholesale gross profit per retail unit fell to $708 from $866, and other gross profit per unit fell to $2,733 from $3,040. Management estimates that elevated fuel prices and rapidly rising benchmark interest rates together cut unit economics by about $200 per unit in the quarter. The 10-Q adds that higher gasoline prices, including from the conflict involving Iran, have pressured consumers' disposable income and raised transportation costs, though these events did not materially affect Q3 results. SG&A rose $210 million to $805 million, driven by headcount, advertising (up to $152 million from $102 million), logistics, fuel, limited-warranty and IT costs tied to volume. SG&A per retail unit nevertheless fell to $3,703 from $3,816. Operating income reached a record $714 million (8.9% margin) against $552 million. Interest expense fell to $98 million from $125 million on the redemption of higher-coupon secured notes. The quarter also carried three below-the-line items: - **Debt extinguishment.** A $53 million loss on redeeming the 2030 notes early. - **Root warrants.** Other expense of $11 million, mainly from the Root warrant exchange. - **Income tax.** A $69 million provision (12.5% effective rate), against a $4 million benefit a year earlier, now that the valuation allowance has been released. Net income was $483 million (6.0% margin), up from $263 million, of which $289 million was attributable to Carvana Co. Diluted EPS was $0.39 against $0.21. Adjusted EBITDA was a record $800 million, up from $637 million, but its margin narrowed to 10.0% from 11.3%. For the nine months, revenue was $21.85 billion (up 48.4%), net income $1.40 billion and Adjusted EBITDA $2.24 billion (10.3% margin). Operating cash flow was $900 million against $606 million: a stronger operating result, higher payables and use of deferred tax assets were partly offset by a $1.0 billion build in vehicle inventory. **Refinancing and balance sheet.** - **Term Loan B.** On August 14, 2026 Carvana entered a credit agreement, with Barclays Bank PLC as administrative agent, for a $1.66 billion senior secured term loan B. It matures August 14, 2033, was issued at 99.75% of par, bears interest at Term SOFR plus 2.25% and has no financial maintenance covenant. - **2030 notes redeemed.** With the proceeds and cash on hand, Carvana redeemed all $1.660 billion of its 2030 Senior Secured Notes (9% cash rate) for $1.711 billion, including a $50 million premium. - **Interest rate swap.** It swapped the floating rate to a fixed 4.055% on a $1.660 billion notional through July 31, 2028. - **Debt and liquidity at quarter-end.** The 2031 Senior Secured Notes ($2.269 billion) are now the only secured notes outstanding. Total debt principal was $5.2 billion at September 30, 2026. Cash was $3.05 billion, and total liquidity resources as the company defines them were $7.50 billion, against $6.74 billion at year-end 2025. **Loan-sale capacity.** On July 27, 2026 Ally raised its forward-flow commitment under the Ally MPSA to up to $8.0 billion of loans through July 26, 2027, from $6.0 billion. One fixed-pool purchase agreement was upsized by $500 million and extended through January 2028, bringing those agreements to $12.5 billion in total. At quarter-end, unused capacity was $6.0 billion under the Ally MPSA and $8.3 billion under the fixed-pool agreements. Carvana sold $2.0 billion of loans to Ally, $1.55 billion through securitizations and $1.6 billion in fixed-pool sales in the quarter. **Root warrant exchange.** On August 31, 2026 Carvana surrendered five tranches of Root warrants, covering about 7.2 million Root Class A shares, in exchange for a new warrant for up to 1.5 million shares that vests in five tranches on insurance-sales milestones and expires August 31, 2028. It also extended its commercial agreement with Root. The exchange produced the $11 million loss noted above. **Operations.** In the quarter Carvana integrated retail production at two more ADESA locations, bringing integrated sites to 21. It began two more full buildouts, making three under construction, all expected to start production in 2027. Fully built-out capacity is about 1.5 million retail units a year, with real estate to support 3 million. Carvana has begun listing new vehicles on Carvana.com from its seven Stellantis franchise dealerships. In the first nine months of 2026 it acquired two more franchise dealerships for $40 million in total consideration ($19 million cash, $21 million of trade vehicle floor plan payables), adding to the five bought in 2025; the 10-Q does not name the dealerships. Website units reached 87,370 and average monthly unique visitors 23.8 million. **Legal and corporate.** - **SEC investigation closed.** In September 2026 the SEC told Carvana it had concluded its investigation tied to the January 2025 short-seller report and did not intend to recommend enforcement action. - **Securities class action.** In the consolidated securities class action in Arizona, the plaintiff moved for class certification on April 6, 2026; Carvana opposes the motion and the court has not ruled. - **Stock split and incentive plan.** On May 5, 2026 stockholders approved the five-for-one forward split of the Class A and Class B common stock, and the 2026 Omnibus Incentive Plan. **Outlook and reporting changes.** For the fourth quarter, management expects a sequential increase in retail units sold, and full-year 2026 Adjusted EBITDA in the higher end of its previously communicated $2.7–3.0 billion range, provided the environment remains stable. Starting in 2027 Carvana plans to make GAAP measures — total gross profit per unit, SG&A, operating income and net income — its primary reporting focus. It will restate its mid-term goal as selling 3 million retail units a year at a 12.5% GAAP operating margin between 2030 and 2035, which it describes as equivalent to its earlier 13.5% Adjusted EBITDA margin target. Beginning with the Q4 2026 earnings call it will stop giving quarterly or annual financial outlooks and focus on progress toward its longer-term goals. ## Subsequent events *From the Q3 2026 Form 10-Q (accession 0001690820-26-000067) and the October 28, 2026 Form 8-K (accession 0001690820-26-000066).* The Q3 2026 10-Q has no separate subsequent-events note and discloses no acquisition, divestiture, new debt issuance or litigation outcome after September 30, 2026. It and the October 28 earnings materials disclose these post-quarter items: - **Finance receivable facility extended.** In October 2026 Carvana amended its $600 million revolving facility with the third of its finance-receivable lenders, which funds loans before they are sold. The amendment extended the maturity from October 9, 2026 to October 15, 2027. The line size was unchanged. - **Reporting and guidance policy.** In its October 28, 2026 shareholder letter Carvana announced the 2027 shift to GAAP-based reporting and targets, and an end to quarterly and annual financial outlooks from the Q4 2026 earnings call (see Outlook above). - **Share count.** As of October 26, 2026, 722,713,745 Class A shares and 380,547,355 Class B shares were outstanding.